Muhammad had sex with a dead body of a woman Lie Exposed !
Posted on: June 3, 2012
- In: All | Allah الله | Christianity | Islam | Jesus | MC-Muhammad [pbuh] | Miss-Conception | Mohammad | muhammad | Prophet Muhammad [pbuh]
- 32 Comments
Muhammad had sex with a dead body of a woman Lie Exposed !
Was Muhammad a necrophile ?
Assalam Alaykum Brother and Sisters,
This Allegation became quite popular these days after the news of Egypt “Necrophilia law” came.
I think this is the best time to Expose this lie ..
The allegation :
Muhammad had sex with Aunt Fatima bint Asad when she was dead.
It is a nonsensical and a malicious claim which is created by Christians just to gain Popularity.
First We will try to find out weather necrophilia (sex with dead body) is allowed in Islamic view or not ? because if the alligation is true then it must be allowed in Islam.
Necrophilia in Islam :
The simplest way to disprove this allegation is to go to Islamic Jurisprudence.
As the charge is that of necrophilia (sex with a dead body) we can look into Islamic theology. If the allegation is true then the act of necrophilia would be allowed in Islam. So what does the expert (Ibn Hajar Haytami) say?
Well, he includes necrophilia in his list of sins [1]. Thus we can realise necrophilia is not allowed in Islam and the Prophet did not engage in such a deed.
In fact if we consult Fiqh we realise “it is unlawful to look at the nakedness of the deceased or touch it” [2].Thus further showing sex with the deceased (dead) cannot possibly be allowed. This further shows the Prophet did not engage in such a deed as if he did then the practice of necrophilia would have been allowed in Islam.
Now We Know that claims of necrophilia against prophet muhammad is lie.We will now see the claim created by Zakria Bothros and the narration and hadith he used to make this false claim.this will also show people the filthy and dirty mind of christians leaders..
Claim By Zakaria Bothros :
This is from a book called “Kanz Al Umal” (The Treasure of the Workers), in the chapter of “The issues of women”, authored by Ali Ibn Husam Aldin, commonly known as Al-Mutaki Al-Hindi. He based his book on the hadiths and sayings listed in “Al-Jami Al-Saghir,” written by Jalal ul-Din Al-Suyuti.
Narrated by Ibn Abbas:
‘I (Muhammad) put on her my shirt that she may wear the clothes of heaven, and I SLEPT with her in her coffin (grave) that I may lessen the pressure of the grave. She was the best of Allah’s creatures to me after Abu Talib’… The prophet was referring to Fatima , the mother of Ali.
“The Arabic word used here for slept is “Id’tajat,” and literally means “lay down” with her. It is often used to mean, “Lay down to have sex.” Muhammad is understood as saying that because he slept with her she has become like a wife to him so she will be considered like a “mother of the believers.” This will supposedly prevent her from being tormented in the grave, since Muslims believe that as people wait for the Judgment Day they will be tormented in the grave. “Reduce the pressure” here means that the torment won’t be as much because she is now a “mother of the believers” after Muhammad slept with her and “consummated” the union. “
Analyzing the Allegation: Authentic?
The Narration
Narrated by Ibn Abbas:
“I (Muhammad) put on her my shirt that she may wear the clothes of heaven, and I SLEPT with her in her coffin (grave) that I may lessen the pressure of the grave. She was the best of Allah’s creatures to me after Abu Talib”… The prophet was referring to Fatima, the mother of Ali.
Looking at the narration alone one would not cry “necrophilia” or any wrong doing as “sex” is not mentioned. However, simply looking at the narration’s English translation one would find it odd. Sleeping with somebody in a coffin (grave) is an odd occurrence indeed. However, once the context is given we realize what actually happened.
The Context and Explanation
Firstly the translation of “I slept” does not best convey the meaning based on the context, the Arabic word translated as “I Slept” is Idtaja’ (اضطجع ). This word can either mean:
lie down, lie, recline, repose [3].
you can check by your self… click below to see meaning in Google translation…
اضطجع
I hope you have noticed within the list of definitions (lie down, lie, recline, repose) the word “sleep” (or “sex”) does not appear.
so,You can see your self how Zakariya Lied about this meaning.
So What Context says ????
did Muhammad sleep or lie in the grave?
The context explains it all, as it was a grave we realize the word cannot possibly mean “sleep” but rather it means “lie/lay in the grave”.
This actually makes sense with the other bits of context we have at our disposal; “When the grave was prepared Muhammad himself examined it and placed her into the grave” [5].
Thus, it is reasonable to think the examination procedure also involved Muhammad lying in the grave. This would not have been at length in terms of duration (time). Therefore we realize Muhammad simply laid in the grave to make sure it was comfortable for his deceased foster mother as well as to honor the lady as it would be seen as a fabulous honor to be resting in a place where a Prophet of God had previously laid.
Did Muhammad Lie with his Foster Mother (Fatima Bint Asad) in the Grave?
It does not appear so as the process of investigating/examining the grave would have been PRIOR (before) lowering Fatima Bint Asad into the grave. Therefore Muhammad would have reclined (lied) in the grave in order to check the grave before Fatima was placed in the grave, thus he would not have lied with her. Furthermore, there were two types of graves in vogue at the time of the Prophet which were Lahd and Shaqq (shiq) .
The Shaqq type of grave is characterized by a niche within the grave for the dead body to be placed within. So it is impossible to lie with the body due to the niche. [8]
The Lahd form of grave is characterized by a lateral hollow which is dug into the side of the base of the grave for the body to be placed [8]. This type of grave makes lying with the deceased body risky as the earth could cave in on top of the body and the one who is lying with the deceased.
Thus, it seems the laying in the grave for examination purposes was done prior to Fatima being lowered into her resting place. This is despite the Arabic phraseology used literally denoting “with”:
اضطجعت معها في قبرها
However, even if one takes it literally it does not mean wrong doing took place and it certainly does not refer to sex.
If Muhammad did lie with his foster mother whilst she was in the grave in order to check for comfort and honor her before the companions filled the grave it would only have been for a short time and this would have been witnessed by other people too. There is nothing wrong with lying in the grave to ensure comfort for your foster mother and honor; in fact it was an act of great compassion.
Checking Zakaria Statements :
Arabic Scholor :
The Arabic scholar Demetrius explains: “The Arabic word used here for “slept” is “Id’tajat,” and literally means “lay down” with her. It is often used to mean, “lay down to have sex.” Muhammad is understood as saying that because he slept with her she has become like a wife to him so she will be considered like a “mother of the believers.
who is “Demetrius”? Zakaria gives no introduction to this scholar. Why?
Have Sex with Her in Order to give her a Special Status?
Zakaria states:
“Muhammad is understood as saying that because he slept with her she has become like a wife to him so she will be considered like a “mother of the believers””
Zakaria’s premise is that Muhammad had sex with Fatima because he wanted her to attain special status as the “mother of the believers”. Well, Zakaria’s premise falls flat on its face because Fatima bint Asad already had the special status of being Muhammad’s foster mother.
In the transcript this information has been withheld (i.e. nobody is told of her special status as the foster mother of Muhammad).
Why is this information not relayed to us in the transcript which is circulating the internet? It is because Zakaria’s premise is thrown into doubt immediately if we are told she already has a special status. Thus if she already had a special status then there would be no need for her to be given the special status of being “like a wife to him” as she was already like a mother to him (Muhammad).
So Father Zakaria’s hypocrisy is fully visible !
“She has become like a wife to him”
Father Zakaria is trying to fool Christians and others. He is claiming Muhammad had sex with Fatima in order for her to have a status of a wife of Muhammad and thus the title of “mother of the believers”.
Zakaria is a dishonest Christian Preacher.
Muhammad could NOT possibly have taken Fatima Bint Asad as a wife as Islamic Law dictates consent be given by BOTH parties in a marriage; of course marrying a dead person would not be allowed simply based on this injunction. Father Zakaria knows this but continues with his fanciful claim because it suits his agenda to besmirch the reputation of the Prophet Muhammad
So the point here is that Fatima could never have become his wife through such an act, despite Father Zakaria’s nonsensical pleadings. Thus Father Zakaria is looking even more foolish in his claim.
“Muhammad did this to save her from the torment of the grave”?
Father Zakaria is showing signs of a fertile imagination and utter ignorance.
If we consult Ahadith literature we will realise Muhammad’s PRAYER made the grave a better abode for people (Hadith) through the grace of God. This shows us if Muhammad seriously felt Fatima Bint Asad was in danger of the punishment of the grave he would have simply PRAYED for her grave to be a better dwelling.
Thus we realise Zakaria’s debauched idea that sex (or marriage) is required to save a person from the punishment of the grave is warped and fallacious to say the least.
“Muslims believed that as people wait for the Judgment Day they will be tormented in the grave”
Zakaria is showing signs of his hypocritical nature. Muslims of course believe in the punishment of the grave but those whom Allah is pleased with are NOT punished. Fatima Bint Asad is considered a saintly woman thus Muslims do not believe she is subjected to the punishment of the grave.
Muslims Belief about Pious Peoples in Grave :
In fact the Muslim belief concerning pious people (such as Fatima Bint Asad) is that their graves will reflect Paradise and will be very comfortable and blissful indeed.
‘The grave is a garden of paradise or a pit of hell.” (Mishkat)
Rasulullah said, ‘The grave is a garden of paradise or a pit of hell.’ (Mishkat).
Concerning the pious people (such as Fatima Bint Asad) “A believer will answer all three questions and he will be honored with the clothing of Jannah. The window of Jannah will be opened for him and he will enjoy the sight of Jannah” (Mishkat)
Thus we realize the grave of a saintly woman (i.e. Fatima Bint Asad) would not be one of torment but of splendor, peace and bliss. She will also see Jannah (Paradise).
What Muhammad did After he heard of his death :
Fatima looked after Muhammad during his youth.
Anas bin Malik says that when Muhammad heard Asad had died, he immediately went to her house sat beside her body and prayed for her soul.
- “My dear mother, may God keep you under His Protection. Many times you went hungry in order to feed me well. You fed me and clothed me on delicacies that you denied yourself. God will surely be Happy with these actions of yours. And your intentions were surely meant to win the Goodwill and Pleasure of God and success in the Hereafter.”
He gave his shirt to be used as part of her shroud. When the grave was prepared Muhammad himself examined it and placed her into the grave. Thus, she was one of the few people whose graves were examined by Muhammad. Fatimah is buried in Jannatul Baqee‘ cemetery in Madinah, Saudi Arabia.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fatimah_bint_Asad
Zakaria’s Hypocrisy
The one making this odd claim is a Christian from Egypt and it just goes to reveal his hypocritical nature because the same word (a construct of Idtaja) is used in the Arabic Bible and it is not translated as sex but is translated as “LAID”. Does Father Zakaria want to be consistent now and withdraw his silly claims?
Please also bear in mind the dictionary references (given earlier) disprove Father Zakaria’s malicious claims and Now the Bible will also disapprove his claim.
The same Arabic word is used in the Bible (2Kings 4:32) and it is translated as “laid” and not sex or anything of that nature:
وَدَخَلَ أَلِيشَعُ الْبَيْتَ وَإِذَا بِالصَّبِيِّ مَيْتٌ وَمُضْطَجعٌ عَلَى سَرِيرِهِ.
English Translation: And when Elisha was come into the house, behold, the child was dead, and laid upon his bed. (KJV)
[The words written in green color,match this word with the word given in start of this Article]
This along with the dictionary references shown earlier just further indicates the narration in question has nothing to do with sex.
This just illustrates Father Zakaria’s ignorance and shows his crackpot idea of Muhammad having sex with his foster mother in order to save her from torment is unadulterated nonsense and a hypocritical mind indeed.
Conclusion
Muhammad was doing what any loving and caring person should do; that was focusing on the well being of his relative (foster mother and aunt, Fatima bint Asad) ) both in this life and the hereafter. There was no sex or wrong doing involved.
This heart warming story of compassion and love for one’s family member is now being hijacked by the debauched and hateful mind of a few who are motivated by hatred and destruction.
Father Zakaria should be ashamed with himself; this man has a poor reputation in the Arab world, both Christians and Muslims will see him as a man looking for controversy and attention whilst viewing him as a crackpot figure.
What they said About Muhammad:
as Muslims believe in Prophet Muhammad [s.a.w] so people can say that Muslims will not believe any thing against Muhammad… but What others(Non-Muslims) believed about him ,those who were truthful in there work and profession ? Lets See…
When ever i read claims from Islam Haters these Quotes of English writers always comes in my mind:
“No great religious leader has been so maligned as Prophet Mohammed. Attacked in the past as a heretic, an impostor, or a sensualist, it is still possible to find him referred to as “the false prophet.” A modern German writer accuses Prophet Mohammed of sensuality, surrounding himself with young women. This man was not married until he was twenty-five years of age, then he and his wife lived in happiness and fidelity for twenty-four years, until her death when he was fourty-nine. Only between the age of fifty and his death at sixty-two did Prophet Mohammed take other wives, only one of whom was a virgin, and most of them were taken for dynastic and political reasons. Certainly the Prophet’s record was better than the head of the Church of England, Henry VIII.”
Geoffrey Parrinder, Mysticism in the World’s Religions (New York: Oxford University Press, 1976, pg. 121)
more quote :
“His readiness to undergo persecution for his beliefs, the high moral character of the men who believed in him and looked up to him as leader, and the greatness of his ultimate achievement all argue his fundamental integrity To suppose Muhammad an impostor raises more problems than it solves. Moreover, none of the great figures of history is so poorly appreciated in the West as Muhammad.”
– W Montgomery Watt Mohammad At Mecca, Oxford, 1953
“The critics are blind. They cannot see that the only ‘sword’ Muhammad wielded was the sword of mercy, compassion, friendship and forgiveness – the sword that conquers enemies and purifies their hearts. His sword was sharper than the sword of steel. But the biased critics of Islam are prejudicial and partisan, who are narrow minded and whose eyes are covered by a veil of ignorance. They see fire instead of light, ugliness instead of beauty and evil instead of good. They distort and present every good quality as a great vice. It reflects their own depravity.”
(Pandit Gyanandra Dev Sharma Shastri)
“His readiness to undergo persecution for his beliefs, the high moral character of the men who believed in him and looked up to him as leader, and the greatness of his ultimate achievement all argue his fundamental integrity To suppose Muhammad an impostor raises more problems than it solves. Moreover, none of the great figures of history is so poorly appreciated in the West as Muhammad.”
– W Montgomery Watt Mohammad At Mecca, Oxford, 1953
I can see how truthful above authors were.Few NonMuslim authors even said “is there any man great than Muhammad” ?
“Philosopher, Orator, Apostle, Legislator, Warrior, Conqueror of ideas, the Restorer of rational beliefs, the preacher of a religion without images, the founder of twenty terrestrial empires and of one heavenly Empire, that is Muhammad. As regards all standards [I repeat, ‘ALL’] by which human greatness may be measured, we may well ask, “Is there any man greater than he?”
(Alphonse Lamartine, French poet)
“If greatness of purpose, smallness of means, and astounding results are the three criteria of human genius, who could dare to compare any great man in modern history with Muhammad? Mohammad established a system based upon true and immortal ideology. Is there any like he?”
(Alphonse Lamartine)
May Allah swt help all of us in exposing lies created by Islam Haters,
May Allah give us strength to stand in front of them,
May Allah forgive our sins and guide us on right path,
May Allah forgive me,if im wrong at any place above,
Ameen,Summa Ameen
Written by
Brother Yahya and King- slave of Allah swt
Kindly Share this Article with source back link ,JazakAllah khair
Read More about Muhammad s.a.w
Muhammad A to Z
Muhammad :: A Role Model
Is there any man greater than he ?
A Day in Life of Prophet
What they said about Muhammad [Video]
Note:I’d love to see who visit my website,your views about website. Click here to leave your feedback.
Stay Connected With Free Updates
 |
 |
 |
If you cannot visit this site everyday and would like to receive our articles everyday via email, please click here and enter your email address in the new window.
PLEASE CHK YOUR EMAIL AFTER SUBMITTING EMAIL,YOU MUST CONFIRM SUBSCRIPTION ! |
Share this :
32 Responses to "Muhammad had sex with a dead body of a woman Lie Exposed !"
January 25, 2013 at 1:27 pm
Alhamdulillah – syukran. People like Zakaria Bothros or Mark a Gabriel for that matter – may be considered as tron – they are potential atheist once ignored by the Christians themselves.
LikeLike
September 29, 2012 at 1:48 am
Thank you for this article. 🙂
“May GOD’s peace, mercy and blessings be upon you.”
LikeLike
September 6, 2012 at 12:31 pm
The title of this article is very disrespectful. As muslims we should have the utmost adab and care when addressing the prophet (sallahualihiwasalam). If the non-muslims are using a derogatory approaches when they mention the prophet (sallahualihiwasalam’s) name then we should not play the same game. In hope they read or hear what we (as muslims) have to say. Know these sorts of attack of the habib (sallahualihiwasalam) will continue up until the day of judgement. We have to address these in the light of islamic adab.
LikeLike
December 6, 2012 at 1:14 pm
The title of the article is the point of view of the non-muslims its how they see the subject of the artcle and in no way is the writter disrespecting muhhammed(pbuh) or allah(swt) he is adressing how the non-muslims see the situation, an i think he’s done a great job, you have to remember that non-muslims visit this site to read aswell so it favours us muslims as to what the truth is on the subject.
LikeLike
August 29, 2012 at 3:45 pm
Please view this video of a 15 year old boy leading witr and share.
LikeLike
August 17, 2012 at 10:34 am
Allah us pagal padri ko hidayat de.
Warna uska thikana jahannam k siwa kuch na hoga.
Yahi log h galat raste pe.
LikeLike
July 26, 2012 at 1:10 pm
Hello i read it.how about the muslim brotherhood which accept this and legalize
LikeLike
June 21, 2012 at 7:28 pm
Assalamu ‘Alaykum WR WB, Jizak Allah Khair for the great article and for defending the honor of our beloved prophet (pbuh) from these imbeciles. Another point that might be good to bring up is that when the prophet (pbuh) laid Fatimah in the grave there were many people around. So how on earth could he have had relations with her in front of all the Companions? Wallahi these guys are sick in the head and all they think of is the worst of the worst. But really they have no many lies I don’t know how anyone can take them seriously. For me once a person is proven to lie and scheme once, I will never take his word seriously again.
LikeLike
June 9, 2012 at 12:56 pm
g
poor zakaria, should check histroy prophet muhammad s.a.w also lay on his daughter grave zainab.i wonder what gain would someone get by defaming prophet muhammad s.a.w.try selling ur religion.
LikeLike
June 6, 2012 at 3:12 pm
shame on Zakaria Bothros hell with Zakaria Bothros
only foolish people follow and belive these saying
and any wise and logical person can found all of these saying is explicit liy with reseaching and reading about bases of islam and goal of islam(please dont notice to what other say find the trusth yourself from true and safe way)
LikeLike
June 4, 2012 at 4:59 pm
Father Zakariyah should be dealt with. Allah will surely deal with soonest as he did for a man who died in an auto accident aiming to burn Quran(matches and quran found on him.
LikeLike
May 5, 2013 at 6:36 pm
Man… this is the attitude that frieghtens non-muslims away from muslims. Can’t it be possible that he was carrying matches to his home to cook dinner?? Why so aggressive and zehadi attitude?? I am not saying that burning quran is good. All i am saying is that you should drop this insensitive behaviour. Think of how others will see that you are being happy that a person died. How come you are sure he was going to burn quran?? be a little sensitive and world will be a good place for all of us to live in. Like brothers..
LikeLike
June 4, 2012 at 11:12 am
all th peace and prayrs of ALLAH be upon our beloved prohpet Mohammed and all the anger and curses of HIS ALMIGHTY be upon the liar, idiot, envious, zakaria bothros
LikeLike
June 4, 2012 at 6:31 am
Tauba Astaghfaar! Crazy people like Fathar Zakriya could only come up with such unimaginable conclusions about Rasool Allah (SAW). Astaghfirullah!! May Allah (SWT) show them the right direction and these Islam Haters stop coming up with illogical explanations about Islam and its Prophet.
LikeLike
June 3, 2012 at 1:18 pm
assalamu alaikum , yesterday I commented but my comment didnt appear, wonder why:[? Anyway I am glad their lies have finally been exposed . laanatullah alalmunafiqun walkufar. ISLAM is a wonderful religion, clean and pure. these are but acts of desperate people clutching at straws!
LikeLike
June 3, 2012 at 7:26 pm
wsalam sister,
yes,you left cmnt,but not in this article…but here…
Egypt ‘necrophilia law’? Hoax ? Facts about “sex after death” law :: News
there i replied to you ,as you said you were hurt,so i published this …Lie Exposure…i thought may be this is the right time..
JazakAllah khair for visit and sharing ur views..
LikeLike
June 3, 2012 at 1:02 pm
This kind of news help the believers to strength even more their own faith against such ignorant people who give testimony of such barbarous invented lies. Every day, in every way, more and more people from different status in society, color, race or religion are testifying the fundamental creed of Islam: “LA ILAHA ILA AL-LAH MUHAMDAN RASULULLAH (there is not god but Al-lah and Muhammad His Messenger) becoming reverted muslims. Stadistically this is a fact that can not be ignored. That’s whiy, those who can not argue with aunthentic consolidated evidences, cowardly are using that type of useless arguments against the Islam and the Muslims. Not doubt fear is conquering their hearts and have not a real helper to mitigate this powerfull and ucontrobable reality of Islam and Muslims. ¡¡AL-LAHu AKBAR!!
LikeLike
June 3, 2012 at 8:32 am
ثم كيف يعيبون علينا ظلما و بهتانا و كتابهم فيه مثل ما يعيبونه على الناس
جاء فى سفر الملوك الثانى الإصحاح 4 الأعداد من 32 – 36 :
32 ودخل اليشع البيت واذا بالصبي ميت ومضطجع على سريره. 33 فدخل واغلق الباب على نفسيهما كليهما وصلّى الى الرب.< 34 ثم صعد واضطجع فوق الصبي ووضع فمه على فمه وعينيه على عينيه ويديه على يديه وتمدّد عليه فسخن جسد الولد.< 35 ثم عاد وتمشى في البيت تارة الى هنا وتارة الى هناك وصعد وتمدّد عليه فعطس الصبي سبع مرّات ثم فتح الصبي عينيه.
و السؤال هنا :
لماذا أغلق اليشع الباب عليه و على الغلام ؟؟
و لماذا تمدد فوقه و وضع فمه على فم الغلام ؟؟
ألا تشعر بريبة مما حدث ؟؟
و ألم يجد الله إلا هذه الوسيلة الرخيصة ليؤيد بها نبيه كمعجزة ؟؟
و إذا كان إحياء الموتى لا يتطلب أن ينام النبى فوق الميت و لا أن يضع فمه على فم الميت
و الدليل :
==
23 ولما جاء يسوع الى بيت الرئيس ونظر المزمرين والجمع يضجون<24 قال لهم تنحوا.فان الصبية لم تمت لكنها نائمة.فضحكوا عليه 25 فلما اخرج الجمع دخل وامسك بيدها.فقامت الصبية ( متى 9 )
.12 فلما اقترب الى باب المدينة اذا ميت محمول ابن وحيد لامّه وهي ارملة ومعها جمع كثير من المدينة.<13 فلما رآها الرب تحنن عليها وقال لها لا تبكي.<14 ثم تقدم ولمس النعش فوقف الحاملون.فقال ايها الشاب لك اقول قم.<15 فجلس الميت وابتدأ يتكلم فدفعه الى امه. ( لوقا 7 )
41 فرفعوا الحجر حيث كان الميت موضوعا ورفع يسوع عينيه الى فوق وقال ايها الآب اشكرك لانك سمعت لي.<42 وانا علمت انك في كل حين تسمع لي.ولكن لاجل هذا الجمع الواقف قلت.ليؤمنوا انك ارسلتني.<43 ولما قال هذا صرخ بصوت عظيم لعازر هلم خارجا.< 44 فخرج الميت ويداه ورجلاه مربوطات باقمطة ووجهه ملفوف بمنديل.فقال لهم يسوع حلّوه ودعوه يذهب ( يوحنا 11 )
فلم يحتاج إحياء الموتى لمثل هذه الطريقة الشاذة
فماذا حدث فى حالة اليشع ؟؟
حسبنا الله و نعم الوكيل
LikeLike
June 3, 2012 at 8:31 am
============================ =============
بالإضافة إن الحديث ضعيف أصلا
عند أئمة الحديث لا يكفي في ثبوت صحته أنه مروي عند الطبراني أو غيره، فقد علم صغار المشتغلين بهذا العلم الشريف أن معاجم الطبراني و كتب السنن و المسانيد وغيرها ماعدا الصحيحين لم تجرد لرواية الصحيح فقط على تفاصيل ليس هذا موضعها،ولكن لابأس ببيان وجه ضعف الحديث و مناقشته على حال الراوي ” روح بن صلاح” الذي زعم هو ومشيخته أن الضعف فيه خفيف،فأقول:
قال العلامة الألباني في سلسلة الأحاديث الضعيفة ( 1 / 79 )وقد أجاد في بيان ضعف هذا الحديث و تناقض القبوريين في التعاطي مع قواعد علم الحديث لتصحيح الأحاديث التي توافق هواهم وضرب على ذلك مثالا :
ضعيف ،رواه الطبراني في ” الكبير ” ( 24 / 351 ـ 352 ) و ” الأوسط ” ( 1 / 152 ـ 153ـ الرياض ) ، و من طريقه أبو نعيم في ” حلية الأولياء ” ( 3 / 121 ) : حدثنا أحمد بن حماد بن زغبة قال روح بن صلاح قال : حدثنا سفيان الثوري عن عاصم الأحول و من طريقه أبو نعيم في ” حلية الأولياء ” ( 3 / 121 ) عن أنس بن مالك قال : لما ماتت فاطمة بنت أسد بن هاشم أم علي رضي الله عنهما … دعا أسامه بن زيد و أبا أيوب الأنصاري و عمر بن الخطاب و غلاما أسود يحفرون … فلما فرغ ،دخل رسول الله صلى الله عليه وسلم فاضطجع فيه فقال … فذكره ، و قال الطبراني : تفرد به روح بن صلاح .
قلت : قال الهيثمي في ” مجمع الزوائد ” ( 9 / 257 ) : و فيه روح بن صلاح وثقه ابن حبان و الحاكم و فيه ضعف ، و بقية رجاله رجال الصحيح .
و في قوله : و بقية رجاله رجال الصحيح نظر رجيح ، ذلك لأن زغبة هذا ليس من رجال الصحيح ، بل لم يرو له إلا النسائي ، أقول هذا مع العلم أنه في نفسه ثقة .
بقي النظر في حال روح بن صلاح و قد تفرد به كما قال الطبراني ، فقد وثقه ابن حبان و الحاكم كما ذكر الهيثمي ، و لكن قد ضعفه من قولهم أرجح من قولهما لأمرين : الأول : أنه جرح و الجرح مقدم على التعديل بشرطه .
و الآخر : أن ابن حبان متساهل في التوثيق فإنه كثيرا ما يوثق المجهولين حتى الذين يصرح هو نفسه أنه لا يدري من هو و لا من أبوه ؟ كما نقل ذلك ابن عبد الهادي في ” الصارم المنكي ” و مثله في التساهل الحاكم كما لا يخفى على المتضلع بعلم التراجم و الرجال فقولهما عند التعارض لا يقام له وزن حتى و لو كان الجرح مبهما لم يذكر له سبب ، فكيف مع بيانه كما هو الحال في ابن صلاح هذا ؟ ! فقد ضعفه ابن عدي ( 3 / 1005 ) ، و قال ابن يونس : رويت عنه مناكير ،و قال الدارقطني : ضعيف في الحديث ، و قال ابن ماكولا : ضعفوه ، و قال ابن عدي بعد أن خرج له حديثين : و في بعض حديثه نكرة .
فأنت ترى أئمة الجرح قد اتفقت عباراتهم على تضعيف هذا الرجل ، و بينوا أن السبب روايته المناكير ، فمثله إذا تفرد بالحديث يكون منكرا لا يحتج به ، فلا يغتر بعد هذا بتوثيق من سبق ذكره إلا جاهل أو مغرض .
LikeLike
June 3, 2012 at 8:28 am
Sorry I meant another Riwayah … even this one ,it’s not authentic (D’eef) … most of the other relative hadiths says that the prophet(PBUH) entered the grave when it was empty >>> before her see:
http://www.soonaa.com/vb/showthread.php?t=464
and
http://www.saaid.net/muslm/6.htm
and
http://mareb.org/showthread.php?t=3617&page=1
and
http://www.trutheye.com/news.php?action=view&id=3684
sorry , but all the sites in Arabic
LikeLike
June 3, 2012 at 8:11 am
Guys … The Hadith about Fatima Bint Asad is very weak (Da’eef Jeddan) so it can’t be used as Daleel or any thing in that matter … and even if we assume that it’s legitimate(Saheeh) .. The prophet (PBUH) when he entered the grave there was no body inside it ,it was empty and he makes Du’aa to her that’s all ….
About this Zakria Butrus … As Always All what he is claiming and saying is bullshit as his mouth is full of shit
LikeLike
June 3, 2012 at 5:58 am
SUBHANALLAH, ISLAM is the fastest growing religion despite the deliberate misconceptions of fanatatism and terrorism imposed by the christian west and America through the media there by creating and developing ISLAMOPHOBIA in the minds of their fellow christians who are ignorantly accepting all these lies against Islam without proof, they’re deprived the right of knowing anything about ISLAM,to know the true teachings of Islam.MAY ALLAH continue to guide us to the straight path. ISLAM IS MY PRIDE.
LikeLike
June 3, 2012 at 5:11 am
may ALLAH (SWT) & his beloved Probhet SYEDI (S A W W) give me power and strength to fight against these bastards in my life, and protect the honor of my SYEDI (S A WW) globally,nSo that no one in this world would dare to do any blasphemy of SYEDI (S A WW)
LikeLike
June 3, 2012 at 1:27 am
Astaghfurullah Al-Adheem………………please don’t post articles like these………there not necessary at all……..Jazakallahkhair.
LikeLike
June 3, 2012 at 1:33 am
When Anyone leave his cmnt… then his computer id is tracked.
If first cmnt is not active then no body can reply to first cmnt.
🙂
i hope you get it,what im saying … right ?
lol
LikeLike
June 3, 2012 at 1:39 am
It is Important sister,The World Must know the true faces of hypocrietes…. and real Muhammad.
There are many Muslims being effected by reading articles filled with lies against Muhammad…not only online even offline..
A christian read his article,in real life if he know muslims he start abusing them.many muslims get hurt from such lies and many left islam too.. so IT IS IMPORTANT.
its a time to know the Real MUHAMMAD.
LikeLike
Oh Allah,Please Forgive me
Ex-Christians-Now Muslim,Alhamdulillah
I Love My Prophet Muhammad s.a.w
ISLAM---World's Greatest Religion! 
February 6, 2014 at 5:17 am
Best response here
LikeLike