“Do not please anyone by angering Allaah” :: Fake(Daeef) Hadith
Posted by: KING-slave of ALLAH ! on: December 13, 2009
- In: All | Allah الله | Fake Hadith | Islam
- Comment!
“Do not please anyone by angering Allaah?”
What is the status of the hadeeth,
“Do not please anyone by angering Allaah, do not thank anyone for the blessings of Allaah, and do not condemn anyone for that which Allaah did not give you. For the provision of Allaah does not come to you because of anyone’s efforts and it is not diverted from you because of anyone’s hatred. By His fairness and justice, Allaah has connected peace and joy to contentment and certain faith, and He has connected worry and distress to discontentment.”
Praise be to Allaah.
This hadeeth was narrated by al-Tabaraani in al-Kabeer, 10/215.
Al-Haythami said:
It was narrated by al-Tabaraani in al-Kabeer, and its isnaad includes Khaalid ibn Yazeed al-‘Umari, who was accused of fabricating hadeeth.
Majmaa’ al-Zawaa’id, 4/71.
It was also narrated – via a different isnaad – by Abu Na’eem in al-Hilyah (5/106) and by al-Bayhaqi in Shu’ab al-Eemaan, 1/221.
Its isnaad includes ‘Atiyah al-‘Awfi, who is da’eef (weak), and the comments of the scholars concerning him have been quoted above (p. 78); and it includes Muhammad ibn Marwaan al-Saddi, who is matrook al-hadeeth (his hadeeth is not to be accepted).
Yahyaa ibn Ma’een said:
he is not thiqah (trustworthy), and on one occasion he said: he is nothing.
Ibraaheem said:
he is kadhdhaab (a liar).
Al-Sa’di said,
he is dhaahib (i.e., his hadeeth is not accepted).
Al-Nasaa’i, Abu Haatim al-Raazi and al-Azdi said: he is matrook al hadeeth (his hadeeth is not to be accepted).
Al-Bukhaari said:
his hadeeth should not be written down. And on one occasion he said: they did not say anything concerning him.
Ibn Hibbaan said:
his hadeeth is not to be written down, and it is haraam to use his hadeeth as evidence.
See Meezaan al-I’tidaal, 6/328; al-Du’afaa’ wa’l-Matrookeen, 3/98
It was also narrated by Hannaad al-Sirri in al-Zuhd, 1/304; and by al-Bayhaqi in Shu’ab al-Eemaan, 1/221, with an isnaad which is mawqoof and stops at ‘Abd-Allaah ibn Mas’ood (may Allaah be pleased with him).
Sheikh Muhammed Salih Al-Munajjid
9 Responses to "“Do not please anyone by angering Allaah” :: Fake(Daeef) Hadith"
September 24, 2010 at 8:12 pm
Brother
May Allah reward you for the good intentions you have and for the effort you are making for deen. Please note the following points relating to the fake hadiths you mentioned.
First:
Weak (daeef) is very different from Fabricated (Mawdoo’). There is Ijma’ that weak hadiths are accepted as long as they are not used for Aqeedah and Halaal/Haraam. So be sure to make the difference between fake and weak.
Second:
Before declaring things the way you do, with so much authority, you need to have a profusion of knowledge on hadith, both riwaaratan and diraayatan. With all due respect to your personality and the work you are doing, I believe you have but very little (I might have less). So please leave this to the specialists.
Third:
And by specialists, I do not mean people like Albani. He is not a muhaddith. He stands against too many of the salafs. When you speak of authorities of hadiths, then your words are acceptable. Albani and the like are very far from being authorities in hadith.
May Allah guide us all.
October 17, 2010 at 8:13 pm
May Allah forgive you brother Abusanaa for the falsehood which you have presented, whether it was intentional or out of ignorance.
1) The Ijma’ which you claimed that weak hadiths are accepted as long as they are not in Aqeedah or Ahkaam, then that is not true! Please provide proof for your claim, for no such consensus exists!
2) Sheikh Al-Albani may Allah have mercy on him have proven himself as the hadith scholar of recent times whether you like it or not. Your claim that many salafis are against him is not true either! Even those who do not like the Sheikh such as the people of innovation and those who belong to deviant sects such as sufis and ash’aris have admitted that the Sheikh is an authority when it comes to hadith. I would suggest you fear Allah and not spread falsehood about the great scholars who have serviced this deen. What have you done that equates to even one-tenth of what this great scholar has done for the hadith of the Prophet peace and blessings be upon him?!
May Allah guide you my brother.
July 12, 2010 at 4:11 am
I am not sure why the validity of this hadith is in question, as it clearly does not contradict Quran. Please expalin…
October 17, 2010 at 8:15 pm
Sister Jana, to determine whether a hadith is authentic or not the scholars go through its chain of narration to see whether the Prophet peace be upon him did in fact say it. It is not whether the hadith “contradicts” the Quran or not how you would determine the authenticity of a hadith.
March 15, 2010 at 1:54 am
Salaam Alaikum WR WB,
If you’re going to claim that a hadith is weak or fake you MUST provide more information. Reasons for it being fake: Weak narration, if so, how? A break in the chain? A corrupt narrator? One transmitter? Contradict an authentic Hadith? Does it violate the Qur’an?
WS
December 14, 2009 at 8:32 am
I dont understand, does it mean that this publication is fake? More light please.
December 14, 2009 at 1:55 pm
thanks for ur visit sister,
No this post is not fake…this post is informing peoples about this fake hadith..
which many peoples may be using,
but now they know the truth and shud stop using this hadith…
and save it self from fire of Hell.as Indeed,
who ever shares lie about prophet(pbuh) is lier and will be sent to Hell…
so,don’t share any fake hadiths…
hope this answer ur query,,,
May Allah protect you from evils and evil acts,
Ameen
Share Your Views Its imp for us :
Subscribe & BookMark
Subscribers and Followers
1000+ Subscribers via Wordpress.
Search
Group / Community / Channel
 |
 |
 |
|
|
Download Holy Quran
Important Topics/Post/Category
Recent Comments
Picture Gallery
 |
 |
Picture Gallery
|
Islamic Wallpapers!
<!--
var EXlogin='islamgr8' // Login
var EXvsrv='s11' // VServer
EXs=screen;EXw=EXs.width;navigator.appName!="Netscape"?
EXb=EXs.colorDepth:EXb=EXs.pixelDepth;EXsrc="src";
navigator.javaEnabled()==1?EXjv="y":EXjv="n";
EXd=document;EXw?"":EXw="na";EXb?"":EXb="na";
EXd.write("Site Status !
nettworkedblog
Islamic Links
You could put your verification ID in a
comment
Or, in its own meta tag
Or, as one of your keywords
Links
Our Google Group
|
| Islam Great Religion |
| Visit this group |
October 26, 2010 at 8:27 am
Dear Bro,
Masha Allah you have done very nice efforts in other areas. I have been spreading your research work. Please continue with your good work. But, be careful when it comes to some issue related with Islamic knowledge.
I clicked on the Fake hadith tab but you are also quoting the weak hadeeths under the same caption. See this is my personal advice leave this matter with scholars of Hadeeth. There are several books on Mowdhoo Ahadeeth for reference contact the Ops on this site http://www.albalagh.net
Regards,
Rehan ahmed